The 2025 season for the Colorado Buffaloes concluded with significant challenges, culminating in a disappointing record of 3-9. As the team reflects on the year, several players emerged as unexpected highlights amid struggles, particularly with the transfer portal class that failed to deliver expected results. Coach Deion Sanders faced challenges in the competitive Big 12 Conference, where the lack of production from key transfers hindered the team’s performance.
Key Standouts from a Difficult Season
One of the most surprising players was sophomore safety Tawfiq Byard. Despite entering the season with a solid reputation, few anticipated he would lead the team with 79 total tackles, including 7.5 tackles for a loss. Byard, who battled injuries throughout the season, became a crucial voice on defense. He stated, “I’m just out there playing with more confidence this season… If I’m out there making plays, I’m out there being communicative and I’m talking.” Unfortunately for the Buffaloes, On3 reported that Byard plans to enter the transfer portal, raising questions about the team’s defensive future.
Another unexpected highlight was redshirt sophomore quarterback Ryan Staub, who started over more heralded players like Kaidon Salter and Lewis in Colorado’s Big 12 opener against Houston. While Staub faced challenges against the Cougars, he made his mark with a standout performance against Delaware. He finished the season with 427 passing yards, three touchdowns, and four interceptions, positioning himself as a potential backup to Lewis for the upcoming season.
Linebacker Jeremiah Brown, a former transfer from Jackson State, also had a breakout year in his final season. Outperforming teammates Martavius French and Reginald Hughes, Brown recorded a career-high 69 total tackles, including 7.5 tackles for a loss and two sacks. His consistent performance was a bright spot in an otherwise challenging season.
Struggles and Opportunities for Improvement
Despite the emergence of these players, not all performances met expectations. Second-year wide receiver Dre’lon Miller struggled significantly on offense, dealing with dropped passes early in the season. Eventually moved to the running backs room, he averaged only 2.9 yards on 46 carries. Coach Sanders expressed optimism about Miller’s transition, noting, “He loves it… he’s learning daily, and I love what I’m seeing.”
Cornerback DJ McKinney also faced challenges, finishing the season with only one interception and five pass breakups. Although opposing quarterbacks often targeted the other side of the field, McKinney’s performance fell short of expectations for a player in that position, leaving his future uncertain.
As the Colorado Buffaloes prepare for the next season, rebuilding efforts will focus on maximizing the potential of emerging players while addressing the shortcomings that plagued the 2025 campaign. The team’s performance highlights the complexities of college football, where the integration of new talent through the transfer portal can significantly impact success.
