Taylor Frankie Paul has sparked speculation about a potential reconciliation with Chase McWhorter amidst her tumultuous romance with Dakota Mortensen. Their complicated history took center stage during the season three finale of the Hulu series, *Secret Lives of Mormon Wives*, which aired on November 13, 2024. During a lunch meeting, Chase offered an apology for his past behavior towards Taylor and her friends, reminiscing about their previous interactions and even jokingly suggesting they should share a kiss.
This new development follows a series of dramatic events surrounding Taylor’s relationships. Prior to the show’s premiere in September 2024, she made headlines due to her involvement in a controversial “soft swinging” scandal while still married to Tate Paul. The scandal involved Taylor’s connections with various couples, including Chase and his then-wife, Miranda McWhorter. During season two, Taylor stated, “Her husband was the one [who] had feelings for me. That’s where the story gets confusing.” She emphasized her perspective, clarifying that she never intended to betray Miranda, who she referred to as a close friend.
The tension escalated when Taylor revealed she had a dream about Chase, which she felt was trivial given their physical interactions during weekends. She noted, “We would blindfold each other, and you would have to guess which husband you were kissing.” Following the fallout, Taylor and Tate ended their marriage, and she later began dating Dakota, welcoming their son, Ever, in 2024. However, their relationship also ended amid rumors of infidelity involving Dakota.
Chase McWhorter, for his part, ended his marriage to Miranda in 2024. He reflected on their relationship, stating, “I think we both realized that we’d gotten married a little prematurely.” He described their current relationship as cordial and friendly, underscoring their commitment to co-parenting their children, Brooks and Cohen.
Chase has also entered the public eye due to his involvement in the soft-swinging controversy, which he explained stemmed from social gatherings during the COVID-19 pandemic. “It was never predetermined that we were going to be doing, like, swinging,” he stated, addressing misconceptions about the events that unfolded.
During the season three finale, Chase surprised Taylor by revealing he had recently ended his relationship with Kate Racker. Their lunch meeting unfolded like a date, as they discussed their past and acknowledged the feelings that had developed between them. Chase complimented Taylor, saying, “Honestly, Taylor, I always thought you were one of the coolest people ever.”
In a confessional, Taylor admitted to being “a very flirty person,” and she noted how natural their chemistry felt. The episode concluded with Chase suggesting they kiss for “old times’ sake.” Despite this moment, Taylor has since taken on a new role as the lead in an upcoming season of *The Bachelorette*, indicating that any rekindling of her connection with Chase may not be on the horizon.
Chase’s involvement in the drama has not gone unnoticed by others in the community, particularly following comments made on his “OnlyDads” podcast, which drew criticism from cast members of *Secret Lives of Mormon Wives*. Mayci Neeley publicly condemned Chase, stating, “Chase is a scumbag,” while Mikayla Matthews voiced concerns about his past behavior towards women in their circle.
As Taylor navigates her new role and the complexities of her relationships, both she and Chase continue to capture public interest, leaving audiences eager to see how their stories unfold in the future.
