UPDATE: aespa member Ningning will not perform at Japan’s 76th NHK Kohaku Uta Gassen due to a storm of controversy and health issues. The girl group’s appearance at one of Japan’s most prestigious music events has ignited fierce backlash following a viral petition that demands a boycott, amassing nearly 90,000 signatures as of this morning.
The controversy erupted over a post made by Ningning, where she shared a photo of a decorative light resembling a mushroom cloud. Critics argue that the image trivializes the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, causing significant outrage among Japanese netizens. Despite SM Entertainment clarifying that the post was made without any political intent, the backlash intensified, leading to calls for the group to withdraw completely from the event.
Earlier today, on December 29, 2025, SM Entertainment announced that Ningning would be sidelined due to health reasons. In a statement, the agency confirmed she was diagnosed with influenza and advised to rest. The remaining members, Karina, Giselle, and Winter, are still set to perform, but this decision has not quelled the rising criticism.
Officials from SM Entertainment acknowledged the backlash in their announcement, stating, “We have received many comments and concerns regarding content that aespa member Ningning posted on social media. While the post was not made with any specific purpose or intent, it nonetheless caused concern among some viewers.”
The decision for the group to still attend the festival has drawn ire from fans and critics alike, with many questioning the wisdom of performing without Ningning. Comments like “They should’ve just not gone” and “Just don’t go. Kohaku isn’t that important” reflect the sentiment among those who believe the group should boycott the event entirely.
This situation puts aespa at a critical crossroads as they face increasing scrutiny and potential damage to their brand. With multiple controversies surrounding the group, including past incidents leading to fan discontent, the current backlash could adversely affect their future opportunities and partnerships.
As the situation develops, fans and industry observers are watching closely. The performance is still scheduled for later this evening, but with the mounting pressure, aespa’s appearance may be overshadowed by the ongoing controversy.
Stay tuned for updates as this story unfolds and more details emerge.
