UPDATE: The Maude family, embroiled in a federal legal battle, held a critical press conference on April 29, 2025, in Dickinson, South Dakota, detailing their recent struggles against felony charges of theft of federal property. This urgent situation has captivated national attention, with significant implications for agricultural producers everywhere.
Charles and Heather Maude first made headlines in early 2025 when the federal government dropped the criminal charges after a lengthy and contentious dispute regarding a historical fence on their ranch. Now, they face renewed challenges as they navigate the legal complexities stemming from a boundary dispute with the U.S. Forest Service.
The Maudes’ ordeal began on March 29, 2024, when local and federal Forest Service agents arrived at their ranch near Scenic, South Dakota, to discuss the historical use of a berm built in 1910. This conversation quickly escalated, revealing that federal agents had trespassed on their property. Despite proving ownership through historical documents, the Maudes were served with felony charges on June 24, 2024, facing up to 10 years in prison and a $250,000 fine.
“There was no intent for us on our part to commit any crime,” Heather stated during the press conference, emphasizing their belief in their legal rights. The couple had just five business days to prepare for their indictment hearing set for July 8, 2025, a timeline that exacerbated their anxiety and uncertainty.
While the charges were formally dropped in a press conference with U.S. Secretary of Agriculture Brooke Rollins, the Maudes made it clear that their battle is far from over. “You can’t resolve an issue like a boundary dispute with the government when you have criminal felony charges facing you,” Heather explained, revealing their ongoing struggle for clarity and resolution.
The couple has recently received a purchase agreement from Tom Schultz, the current chief of the Forest Service, allowing them the option to buy the disputed land under the Small Tracts Act. “We’re reviewing it and will sign soon,” said Heather, presenting a glimmer of hope for resolution.
However, they remain hesitant about how to respond to the criminal charges. “We have a list of attorneys that would love to take them on, and we would rather not,” she shared, hinting at a potential informal agreement with Chief Schultz to avoid further litigation.
The Maudes urged attendees and the public to stay informed as they navigate this complex situation. “We appreciate everyone continuing to follow our situation,” Heather concluded, highlighting the community’s support during these challenging times.
For continuous updates, follow The Dickinson Press and the Maude family’s social media. More information about the North Dakota Farm Bureau, which organized the event, can be found at www.ndfb.org.
